Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | griffinli's commentslogin

Hue does support Matter. Hue is expensive but delivers a premium experience, unlike the products talked about in this thread that are expensive but not better than the competition.


Free markets are great.


It's possible they do that, but it's difficult to block third-party clients entirely. Changes to APIs can generally be worked around.


That can work for two apps but it's tedious once there are three or more. You'd also need to swipe back and forth between apps to find the corresponding prices for each ride type (Wait & Save, Standard, Comfort, etc.), whereas this app groups together the prices for each ride type across providers.


That's a valid concern but I think it's unlikely. No one's account has been locked for using this app. Rideshare companies take a large cut of the ride fare, so locking user accounts for using third-party apps is against their incentives. It's more likely that they would try to prevent this app from working, rather than targeting users of the app.


Not a ban, perhaps... but if I have two users - Alice who uses the app according to normal patterns, and Bob who consistently predicts and declines when my dynamic pricing algorithm tries to push above market pricing, and has a remarkably high look-to-book ratio - I'll want Alice to have better drivers, better service, faster pickups etc., because I'll have larger lifetime margins from choose-the-app-on-vibes-Alice than from race-to-the-bottom-Bob.

If my known-good supply is limited at any given time, I have every incentive to focus it on Alice, and I'd be inclined to try out e.g. new drivers on accounts like Bob's.

Rideshare data teams are incredibly talented, capable, and motivated. One does not simply front-run a market where the biggest players have a massive data advantage, control your latency, and are effectively unregulated.


An alternative possibility is that a rideshare company sees that Alice always takes the price that's offered so Alice receives the standard price, whereas Bob is price-sensitive so he receives personalized discounts on rides until the prices reach the amount that he's willing to pay.


Which is a competitive success story. It's much more profitable to avoid competition with abusive dynamic pricing and punish users for price-shopping.


This is what most airlines and hotels do, the best prices go on google flights and google hotels and the worst prices are in their own apps.


That's exactly right. This is a big market and this gives consumers another option to choose best priced rides. Think like you mentioned such as booking.com, sky scanner, Agoda, Expedia etc etc. Competition is good.


Race-to-the-bottom Bob belongs with the likes of Ben Bitdiddle and Louis Reasoner


App Review didn't object to that. There are various apps on the App Store today that rely on reverse engineering, such as unified messaging apps, alternative rideshare price comparison apps, and driver-side rideshare aggregators.


I believe this is Google's rule that applies. Though, I think Beeper would be breaking it as well. Maybe I'm reading it wrong?

> Examples of common Device and Network Abuse violations:

> Apps that access or use a service or API in a manner that violates its terms of service.


I guess they don't really enforce it. Zenmoney reverse-engineered APIs of banking apps and their app is still on both app store and google play


IANAL but I also wonder if app A can violate app B's terms of service, if they never agreed to the TOS in the first place.


Interesting. App store asked me for proof of permission from the first party to use a reverse engineered BLE protocol.


App Store review is really just luck of the draw in my experience. There is usually no rhyme or reason to a decision, changing some minor thing and re-applying works a lot of the time.


What project was this?


That's planned!


It works throughout the US and Canada.


No, just mobile.


What's your Android method? I use Apple Configurator too.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: