Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Hm, which is worse: An entire country of millions of people suffers from the shortsighted actions of a few with reduced quality of products, increased prices, worse access to other countries, and a host of other problems...

...or we have to listen to some people whine?



> Hm, which is worse: An entire country of millions of people suffers from the shortsighted actions of a few

Few? 51% is a few? I mean, I also think Brexit was a monumentally stupid decision, but 51% of people wanted it, no?

Even assuming that everyone who didn't vote would have voted for remain, given the voter turnout of 71% (which is already very high for any election, typical turnout is around 57%), 35% of people said yes. That's not a few, that a big chunk.


The biggest issue is that at the time of the vote, nobody had any idea of what Brexit actually meant. The leave campaign could literally promise anything and a) they wouldn’t have to deliver it and b) everyone who voted for Brexit can reasonably suggest that they voted for something other than what was actually delivered.

The best you can say about the Brexit vote is that 51% wanted something other than the status quo.


What if 51% weakly want something and 49% strongly want the opposite?


If 51% of the population weakly wanted something they would lose the vote because most wouldn't bother voting. Didn't happen here.


Strongly enough to vote for it.


The "few" I'm talking about are the politicians who pushed for the referendum, and the politicians and media execs that cheerfully portrayed it as if Brexit was going to cause Europe to give the UK everything it wanted with zero drawbacks or tradeoffs, as if they were still the Mighty And Unchallengeable British Empire.

And in any case, the point of my post was the "suffering", not the "few".


That's a good point, but sometimes it's a good thing for people to see the consequences of their (and others') choices. Perhaps it could have some good medium / long-term effects.


The winners are still whining anyway.


More like “we won, don’t mention it”

It was recently the 10-year anniversary of the Brexit vote. Not a single firework.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: